Global crude oil prices have significantly declined in recent weeks, with the variety of crude oil that India imports currently priced at around ₹573 per barrel. This marks the lowest level since November 2021, just before Russia’s invasion of Ukraine caused a spike in global oil prices. Many expect this reduction in crude oil prices to translate into lower fuel costs for consumers. However, governments around the world, including India, seem reluctant to pass these savings on to consumers, leaving fuel prices high. This reluctance is driven by a complex mix of economic, fiscal, and political considerations, making the decision to cut fuel prices far from straightforward.
The Complex Dynamics Between Crude Oil and Retail Fuel Prices
It’s important to recognize that the relationship between crude oil prices and local fuel costs is not direct. While crude oil is the main input in producing petrol and diesel, its price makes up only part of what consumers pay at the pump. In many countries, a large portion of fuel prices is driven by taxes, refining, distribution, and other operational costs. In countries like India, fuel taxes, which are among the highest in the world, form a substantial part of the final price.
In India, both the central and state governments impose hefty taxes on fuel. The central excise duty and state-level value-added tax (VAT) together account for a significant portion of the price consumers pay for petrol and diesel. In some cases, these taxes make up more than 50% of the total cost. Therefore, even if crude oil prices drop, it does not necessarily mean that fuel prices will fall proportionally for consumers.
Governments’ Dependence on Fuel Taxes for Revenue
One of the primary reasons for the reluctance to lower fuel prices is the substantial revenue that governments generate from fuel taxes. In India, for instance, both central and state governments heavily rely on excise duty collections from petroleum products to support their budgets.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, when crude oil prices were at record lows, the Indian government raised excise duties on petrol and diesel multiple times to make up for revenue shortfalls. With the economy struggling and tax collections from other sources dwindling, fuel taxes became a lifeline for the government, helping to fund various welfare programs and provide economic relief.
Reducing fuel prices by cutting taxes would lead to a significant reduction in government revenue. In a country like India, which already faces fiscal deficit concerns, slashing fuel taxes could hinder the government’s ability to finance essential services, welfare schemes, and public infrastructure projects. This fiscal pressure becomes even more critical when factoring in the ongoing need for public spending in areas such as healthcare, education, and infrastructure.
Balancing Inflation Control and Fiscal Responsibility
Another major consideration for governments is the effect of fuel prices on inflation. Petrol and diesel are essential inputs in sectors such as transportation and logistics. When fuel prices rise, the cost of transporting goods also increases, driving up the prices of essential commodities like food and other consumer goods. This fuels inflation, which can erode the purchasing power of consumers and dampen economic growth.
While reducing fuel prices can help curb inflation, cutting taxes to achieve this goal may not always be the best approach. Governments need to strike a balance between inflation control and maintaining fiscal health. Direct interventions, such as providing subsidies or targeted financial assistance to low-income households, may be more effective in combating the inflationary impact of high fuel prices without risking fiscal instability.
Moreover, while lower fuel prices can ease inflationary pressures, governments must also weigh the political risks. In countries like India, where the middle and lower-income groups are highly sensitive to fuel price changes, rising fuel costs often lead to public outcry and protests. However, slashing fuel taxes during times of lower crude oil prices might not be sustainable in the long term, especially if oil prices rise again or new economic challenges arise.
The Unpredictability of Global Oil Markets
Another reason why governments are hesitant to reduce fuel prices is the inherent volatility of global oil markets. Crude oil prices are subject to rapid and unpredictable fluctuations due to factors such as geopolitical tensions, supply chain disruptions, and global demand changes. While crude oil prices have recently fallen, there is no guarantee that this trend will continue in the near future.
If oil prices were to rise sharply again, governments that had reduced fuel taxes in response to falling prices could face a difficult choice: either reintroduce higher taxes and face public backlash or absorb the higher costs through increased subsidies, which would strain their fiscal resources. The fear of such price volatility often makes policymakers cautious about reducing taxes in response to short-term dips in crude oil prices.
Energy Transition and Environmental Concerns
Governments are also mindful of the need to reduce reliance on fossil fuels and transition to cleaner, more sustainable energy sources. Lowering fuel prices by cutting taxes could slow down the adoption of alternative energy solutions such as electric vehicles (EVs) and renewable energy. It could also lead to higher fossil fuel consumption, undermining efforts to reduce carbon emissions and combat climate change.
In India, for example, the government has been promoting EV adoption and investing in renewable energy projects as part of its commitment to reducing carbon emissions. Lowering fuel prices through tax cuts could make petrol and diesel more attractive to consumers, thereby reducing the incentive to switch to cleaner energy alternatives.
International Comparisons: How Other Nations Handle Fuel Price Reductions
India is not the only country grappling with the challenge of managing fuel prices in the face of fluctuating crude oil prices. Many nations, especially those in Europe, impose high taxes on fuel as part of their strategy to reduce carbon emissions and promote sustainable energy. Even when global oil prices fall, these countries often hesitate to reduce taxes, as they rely on the revenue to fund environmental initiatives and discourage excessive fuel consumption.
In the United States, fuel taxes are relatively low compared to other nations, but individual states impose their own fuel taxes, which can vary significantly. Despite the recent decline in crude oil prices, fuel prices in the US remain elevated due to supply chain bottlenecks and refinery capacity issues.
A Complex Balancing Act
The decision to cut fuel prices is far more complex than it might initially appear. Governments need to consider a range of factors, including fiscal stability, inflation control, energy transition goals, and public sentiment. In countries like India, where fuel taxes make up a significant portion of government revenue, reducing fuel taxes could undermine the government’s ability to fund critical programs and services. At the same time, high fuel prices can contribute to inflation and erode public support, making it a politically sensitive issue.
Ultimately, governments face the difficult task of balancing these competing priorities. While consumers may expect lower fuel prices when global crude oil costs decline, the reality is that governments must carefully consider the broader economic and fiscal implications before making such a decision. Policymakers need to adopt a long-term perspective, ensuring that any changes to fuel pricing policy align with fiscal sustainability, inflation control, and the transition to a greener, more sustainable energy future.
Disclaimer: The thoughts and opinions stated in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views or positions of any entities represented and we recommend referring to more recent and reliable sources for up-to-date information.
